Florentine Pastry Shop Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Florentine Pastry Shop, a hidden gem nestled in Utica, NY, that promises to enchant your palate with its artisanal pastries. This delightful bakery offers an impressive menu that caters to all sweet cravings, featuring an array of exquisite treats from classic Cannoli ($2.25) to the decadent Tiramisu ($3.00). Each bite transports you to Italy, with flavors that evoke nostalgia and joy.

Highlights include the seasonal Pasticciotti and the irresistible Chocolate Covered Cannoli ($2.75), showcasing the shop's dedication to traditional recipes and quality ingredients. For those seeking a special occasion cake, options range from 6” to 10” sizes, perfect for any gathering.

Beyond pastries, savor a cup of freshly brewed Cappuccino ($2.80) to complement your treat. With convenient takeout, delivery, and outdoor seating, Florentine Pastry Shop is a must-visit for dessert lovers!

Pastries

Cannoli

$2.25

Chocolate Covered Cannoli

$2.75

Pasticciotti "Pustie"

Chocolate, vanilla, lemon, raspberry, coconut (seasonal), pumpkin (seasonal), & apple

$2.25

Italian Cheesecake

$2.25

Sfogliatelle

"Sfoo-yah-tell"

$2.75

Cannoli Cheese Eclair

$2.25

Vanilla Cream Puff

$2.25

Chocolate Covered Eclair

$2.50

Whipped Cream Puff

$2.50

Florentine Kiss

$2.25

Peanutbutter Bombe

$2.25

Rum Napoleon

$2.50

Raspberry Napoleon

$2.50

Tiramisu

$3.00

Ny Style Mini Cheesecake

$2.00

Cannoli Napoletano

$2.00

Italian Cookies

$16.00

Rum Baba

$2.50

Lobster Tail

$5.00

6" Cake

Serves 6

$13.00

8" Cake

Serves 10

$21.00

9" Cake

Serves 12

$26.00

10" Cake

Serves 16

$32.00

8x12" Cake

Serves 24

$48.00

Cakes

Coffee

Cappuccino

$2.80

Espresso

$1.80

Regular Coffee

$1.85